Why Do We Rehearse Conversations That Haven't Happened Yet?
When your mind prepares for conflict, but your body is already reacting.
You're in the shower, having a heated discussion with your coworker about something they said yesterday.
You explain exactly why they were wrong. You anticipate their excuses. You deliver the perfect response, calmly but firmly. And when they try to interrupt, you've already got your comeback ready.
By the time you turn off the water, you've won the argument.
There's just one problem.
The conversation never happened.
And perhaps it never will.
Most of us have done something similar. We've mentally practiced an uncomfortable conversation, imagined someone's reaction, or replayed an argument while coming up with better things we could have said.
Sometimes these mental rehearsals help us prepare. Other times, they leave us irritated, anxious, or emotionally exhausted.
What's particularly interesting is that we can experience all those feelings without ever speaking to another person.
Why does our mind do this? Why can an imaginary conversation feel so real? And what would happen if we no longer needed to prepare ourselves emotionally for every possible disagreement?

Your Brain Is a Prediction Machine
Our brains are constantly trying to figure out what might happen next. This ability helps us navigate daily life, make decisions, and prepare for unfamiliar situations.
When we anticipate an important conversation, our minds naturally begin exploring possibilities.
What should I say? How might the other person respond? What if they disagree?
This kind of mental preparation can be helpful. It allows us to organize our thoughts, consider another person's perspective, and approach a conversation with greater confidence.
But sometimes our minds go beyond preparation.
Instead of considering a few possibilities and moving on, we become caught in an endless search for the perfect response.
We imagine objections, misunderstandings, criticism, and rejection. We develop explanations for things nobody has questioned and defenses against accusations nobody has made.
It's as though our brain has decided that if we can predict every possible outcome, nothing will catch us off guard.
Unfortunately, people aren't predictable. No matter how thoroughly we prepare, we can't control what someone else will think, feel, or say.
And that uncertainty can be uncomfortable.
The interesting question is why uncertainty bothers some of us so much more than others.
The Conversation Is Imaginary. The Feelings Are Real.
Consider someone preparing to ask their employer for a raise.
They've researched comparable salaries, documented their accomplishments, and chosen an appropriate time to talk.
They're well prepared.
Yet every time they think about approaching their boss, their stomach tightens. They imagine being turned down, appearing greedy, or being told their work isn't valuable enough.
Suddenly, asking for a raise isn't simply a business discussion. It feels like a personal judgment of their worth.
Their body may respond with a racing heart, tense muscles, or an uncomfortable sensation in the chest.
This is where the connection between imagination and emotion becomes fascinating.
In a 2010 review published in Clinical Psychology Review, researchers Emily Holmes and Andrew Mathews examined how mental imagery influences emotional experiences.
Their findings showed that vividly imagining emotional situations can produce powerful emotional responses, sometimes stronger than simply thinking about those situations in words.
Our brains can respond emotionally to what we imagine, even when we know it isn't happening.
This doesn't mean our brains literally cannot distinguish imagination from reality. They can. But imagining a situation can still activate emotional and bodily responses associated with that experience.
We don't have to be in a difficult situation to experience the emotions connected with it.
And once those feelings appear, our minds may become even more determined to prepare for whatever we're anticipating.

Are We Preparing for a Conversation—or Protecting Ourselves From a Feeling?
Here's an interesting possibility.
Maybe we're not always rehearsing conversations because we don't know what to say.
Maybe we're rehearsing because we don't want to experience how we think the conversation will make us feel.
Think about someone who struggles to say no.
A neighbor asks them to help organize another community event. Their calendar is already full, and they really don't want to take on another responsibility.
The answer should be simple.
"Thanks for thinking of me, but I can't do it this time."
Yet they spend the entire evening mentally preparing excuses.
They imagine the neighbor looking disappointed. They worry about being considered selfish or unhelpful. They practice different explanations, hoping to find one that won't upset anyone.
What makes this situation difficult?
It may not be the conversation itself.
It may be the guilt they anticipate feeling if someone is disappointed in them.
For another person, the uncomfortable feeling might be embarrassment, rejection, criticism, or fear of conflict.
The words change, but the underlying concern is similar.
We're trying to protect ourselves from an emotional experience we don't want to have.
Psychologist Thomas Borkovec and his colleagues explored worry in a 1983 study published in Behaviour Research and Therapy. Their research described worry as a pattern of thought frequently focused on future possibilities and associated with anxiety and physical tension.
Worry can feel productive because we're mentally working on a problem. But repeatedly imagining what might go wrong doesn't necessarily make us better prepared.
Sometimes we're simply practicing being upset.

When Thinking Becomes a Habit
There's another side to imaginary conversations: the ones we have about things that already happened.
You leave a social gathering feeling perfectly fine. Later that evening, you remember a comment you made during dinner.
Was it inappropriate? Did someone misunderstand? Why did everyone go quiet afterward?
You start reviewing the evening, looking for clues.
Perhaps you decide you should have explained yourself differently. Then you wonder whether you should send a message to clear things up.
Before long, an enjoyable evening has turned into an investigation of something that might not have been a problem at all.
Psychologists call this kind of repetitive thinking rumination.
In a 2008 review published in Perspectives on Psychological Science, Susan Nolen-Hoeksema and her colleagues examined how rumination affects emotional well-being.
Their research found that repetitive negative thinking can prolong distress, encourage negative interpretations, and interfere with effective problem-solving.
The important distinction is between reflection and rumination.
Reflection can help us learn from an experience, understand another perspective, or decide what to do differently next time.
Rumination keeps us circling the same questions without reaching a useful conclusion.
It's like watching the same movie repeatedly, hoping the ending will change.
And sometimes, the more we think about an experience, the more emotionally significant it becomes.
What started as a passing concern can grow into something that occupies our attention for hours or even days.
Why Knowing Better Doesn't Always Make Us Feel Better
One of the most frustrating things about these imaginary conversations is that we often recognize what we're doing.
We know we're overthinking.
We know the situation probably won't unfold the way we're imagining.
We might even recognize that we're being unreasonable.
Yet that understanding doesn't necessarily stop the emotional response.
Consider someone who's uncomfortable receiving compliments.
A colleague praises their presentation, and everyone else seems pleased for them. But instead of enjoying the recognition, they feel embarrassed and want to change the subject.
They may understand intellectually that compliments are positive and that they deserve recognition.
Still, the discomfort appears automatically.
They can tell themselves to relax, smile, and accept the compliment graciously. They may even become quite good at doing so.
But inside, the same uncomfortable reaction remains.
This illustrates an important difference between managing an emotional response and resolving it.
Managing emotions can be valuable. We can learn to pause before responding, challenge unrealistic thoughts, practice mindfulness, and communicate more effectively.
These skills help us navigate difficult situations.
But emotional reactions aren't created by conscious thinking alone. They involve complex interactions among the brain, nervous system, bodily sensations, memories, and our interpretation of events.
That's why simply understanding a reaction doesn't always make it disappear.
And it raises an interesting question.
What if we could address the emotional response itself, rather than continually trying to change the thoughts surrounding it?
A Different Approach: Emotional Resolution®
Emotional Resolution® (EmRes®) approaches recurring emotional reactions from a different direction.
Rather than focusing primarily on analyzing thoughts, revisiting past experiences, or developing better coping strategies, EmRes works with the physical sensations associated with an emotional response.
The approach is based on the idea that the body has a natural capacity to process and resolve certain emotional reactions when given the appropriate conditions.
EmRes practitioners guide clients through this body-based process, with the goal of resolving the emotional trigger rather than simply helping someone manage its effects.
Let's look at how this might apply to someone who regularly rehearses difficult conversations.
Imagine a woman who has recently accepted a leadership position.
She's experienced, capable, and respected by her colleagues. Yet whenever she needs to correct someone's work or deliver disappointing news, she feels uneasy.
She knows how to communicate professionally. She's attended leadership training and understands the importance of clear expectations.
But before each difficult discussion, she spends hours worrying about how the other person will react.
What if they become angry? What if they don't like her anymore? What if they think she's unfair?
She doesn't need another lesson in communication.
She already knows what to say.
What she struggles with is the emotional discomfort associated with the possibility of someone being unhappy with her.
Through EmRes, she could work with that specific emotional reaction as it appears in the present.
She wouldn't need to search her childhood for the reason she dislikes disappointing people. She wouldn't need to retell every uncomfortable experience or convince herself that her feelings are irrational.
The focus would be on the emotional response itself.
If that reaction resolves, she may discover that she can approach difficult discussions without the same apprehension.
She can still be thoughtful and considerate. She can still care about her employees' feelings.
But she may no longer feel responsible for preventing every uncomfortable reaction another person might have.
The goal isn't to become less caring. It's to become less emotionally burdened by uncomfortable and often conflicting and confusing emotions.
Although EmRes is intended to produce lasting changes in emotional reactions, individual experiences vary, and research specifically evaluating its effectiveness is still developing.

What Changes When We're No Longer Preparing for Emotional Battle?
Imagine approaching an important discussion without feeling the need to control every possible outcome.
You know what you want to communicate, but you don't need a script for every response.
You can listen without immediately becoming defensive.
You can disagree without feeling personally attacked.
And you can accept that someone else might be disappointed, frustrated, or unhappy without automatically taking responsibility for those feelings.
This doesn't mean difficult conversations suddenly become enjoyable.
Nor does it mean we should ignore genuine problems, tolerate disrespect, or stop preparing for important discussions.
Healthy preparation still matters.
The difference is that preparation can become a practical activity rather than an emotional necessity.
Instead of rehearsing because we're afraid of what might happen, we can prepare because we want to communicate clearly.
That distinction can change how we approach relationships, workplace challenges, family responsibilities, and everyday disagreements.
It can also free up an enormous amount of mental energy.
Think about how much attention becomes available when we're no longer spending hours anticipating problems, reviewing past conversations, or searching for the perfect response.
We have more room to focus on what's actually happening around us.
And perhaps more importantly, we become better able to respond to real people rather than the imaginary versions we've created in our minds.
You Don't Have to Win Every Conversation
There's something wonderfully freeing about realizing that we don't have to prepare a defense against every possible criticism, misunderstanding, or disagreement.
We don't have to convince everyone that we're right.
We don't have to prevent other people from feeling disappointed.
And we certainly don't have to spend our evenings participating in arguments that exist only in our imagination.
Of course, our minds will continue anticipating future events. That's part of being human, and it's often helpful.
The goal isn't to stop thinking ahead.
It's to recognize when useful preparation has turned into an emotionally exhausting exercise.
Sometimes the answer is better communication. Sometimes it's a practical decision, a clearer boundary, or a willingness to accept uncertainty.
And sometimes, the emotional reaction driving all that mental rehearsal may be something we can address directly.
Emotional Resolution offers one approach to exploring that possibility.
Because the real freedom isn't having the perfect response ready for every conversation.
It's knowing that even when a conversation doesn't go your way, you can still be okay.
Discover how Emotional Resolution® may help you spend less time managing emotional reactions and more time enjoying everyday life.
Visit Emotional Health Institute.
References
Holmes, E. A., & Mathews, A. (2010). Mental imagery in emotion and emotional disorders. Clinical Psychology Review, 30(3), 349–362.
Borkovec, T. D., Robinson, E., Pruzinsky, T., & DePree, J. A. (1983). Preliminary exploration of worry: Some characteristics and processes. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 21(1), 9–16.
Nolen-Hoeksema, S., Wisco, B. E., & Lyubomirsky, S. (2008). Rethinking rumination. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 3(5), 400–424.
Images by AIDocMaker.com
About Sue
Sue Siebens uses Emotional Resolution, EmRes, to work at a fundamental level, where the roots of the illness, fear, and pain can be accessed and resolved. Sue teaches and writes to raise awareness about this new technology so that as many people as possible can find relief and peace in their life. Sue is based in Ft Worth, Tx, USA.




Comments